You are viewing [info]astolat's journal

atlantis desperately earnest

SGA: Under The Sea, John/Rodney, for [info]svmadelyn's badfic challenge

Okay, so first I totally did not realize this was a 48-hour challenge until TOO LATE, and then on top of it the damn thing ran away with me, and, and, okay, it's my fault, I'm sorry! *creeps away*

For [info]svmadelyn's badfic-summary challenge, summary from [info]hyperfocused: Rodney MmmKay's mother always told him smart boys never get the hot guys. Can he pretend to be dumb so hunky pilot John Shep Hard will ask him to the Atlantis: Under the Sea prom? W/ my OC Princess Ancienta. Warnings: ANGST M/M plz rd/rvw

Oh yeah. :P

Under The Sea (4500 words)
Rodney/John
Tiaras! Bacon! Rock-throwing!

( Read the story )

eta to change to permanent link! :)

Many thanks to MissP for getting me unblocked, to Hth and Terri and Ces and giddy and Julad for looking at this wacky, wacky thing for me. *g*
Tags: ,

Comments

Page 1 of 7
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] >>
Oh, this is a perfect response to the challenge--of course Rodney couldn't fake being dumb for long--or at all, really. Fantastic!
Who doesn't love an adolescence AU? No one! Certainly not me.

Nice handling of the prompt, plus, I love this Rodney - young and still figuring himself out, but still clearly himself, flaws and virtues alike.

Poor Morgenstern is going to have to pay for that monitor out of his budget, isn't he.... *g*
Awwwwww. Also, John being Princess Ancienta is just perfect.
This is awesome and hot. Plus "I'm—I'm taking Liz from Sigma Gamma Alpha." sent me into a gigglefit.
God, I loved this. It was absolutely brilliant with the fumbling sex and the tutoring by yelling and the whole conversation between Rodney and Morgenstern at the end was hilarious and then the sex in the lab was absolutely perfect.

Thanks!
"I'm—I'm a pinrcess," he announced to the room at large

Yes, John. Yes, you *are* a pinrcess, and we love you for it.

Additionally: stories like this are the *reason* I keep following links with summaries like, "Rodney takes dance lessons," or "John is actually the last in a line of Ancient princes with magikal powers." The crack in this fandom is just so damn deceptive.
Sometimes when I read a story, it takes me a while to get into it. At other times, I may have to re-read bits.

But I can definitely say that after I read your opening sentence, I was hooked on this story and I knew I had to read on...

Betrayed and miserable, Rodney stood outside the locked lab door. He pressed his hands flat against the glass window and leaned in so close his nose was squashed against the pane, staring longingly and in anguish at the beautiful shiny humming supercomputer in the back of the room...

I could see a young Rodney, big blue eyes glazed over, nose pressed against the window, almost crying at his loss!

And that drew me in.

I loved this story... I loved fratboy John and I loved the idea of Rodney coaching the boys! I liked that Ford and Lorne were there and best of all, I love the ending with it romantic overtones... but seriously, he actually sleeps in the lab?

Thanks so much for sharing! Wish I had your talent for writing. :XD
:cough: most art students happily sleep in their studios.
The thing I love most about this is that Rodney gets laid in his lab, it's like heaven!
I had way too much fun reading that! Thank you. :)
*HART*

Oh, man... I think college!boys are possibly my favorite AU type. This is just so funny and so so hot, and such a wonderful interpretation of the prompt and THANK GOD you went over the word limit! This was wonderful! *g*
ohmigod, he broke a LCD!

*coughs*

Loved the fic, especially Rodney being 'kinda' accepted into the frat for his uber-smartness. And the idea of Rodney torturing his thesis advisor for the lab keys made my day.
Awww! So neat! Rodney! And John! And cufflinks! And sleeping bag! And! And! Physics!
Oh, John, I'm heartily thankful for the tiara.

Very much fun. :)
this was a lot of fun to read. :) thanks so much for sharing. Wondeful take on the prompt. If only all badfic was this good. :)
Oh, Rodney. Despite being nineteen, you're still the least convincing Physics 101 student ever. But what a tutor!
*bounces* Oh, that was fantastic. *cackles*
oh this is fabulous.

*nods*
somehow the physics groupies he'd anticipated hadn't quite materialized

LOL!!

"You went to a frat party and tutored them in physics?" Morgenstern pulled out his chair and sat down and rubbed his face. "Of course you did."

Hee!! That was my favorite scene.

Great "badfic"!
see, this is the good crack. The kind of crack that totally could have happened, if you gloss over the part where it, you know, didn't. Despite the cracktacular situation, the characters are still completely recognizable and believable, and - starting with a summary like this - that's pretty incredible.

Rodney is the best. He's just - wow. yeah. Tutoring the frat boys, and then, before that, his princess atlantia comment - God. He wins so hard at life.

yay!
In desperation, Rodney girded his loins and went down to the quad.

Oh god, Rodney's loins. Brilliant.

It was a scene out of nightmares and Porky's Revenge.

This is the best sentence ever. The perfect set up. And then the party, oh god the party is incredible and everything just flows beautifully from there. Rodney and his GENIUS, and how he's still Rodney and this is still young AU Rodney, but he's not helpless and humiliated, like he is sometimes in other fics... he's wonderful. And John knows how wonderful he is and he gets it before Rodney does. I love it.

And John's slouching and ambling is great. And then he does this:

"Are you deaf or something? I've been throwing pebbles for ten freaking minutes, I thought I was going to have to break the window," John said.

And wow, it's that great romantic gesture that we all know and love.

Such nice work here, thank you!

:D

Brilliant as always. I had a grin on through the whole story. Sweet and cute. And just wonderful. Yay.

And I'm sorry I haven't said this already, but again, thank you, thank you, thank you for the "Lawrence of Arabia" story. it was so utterly, absolutely wonderful that I don't have words to say how much I love it.
Hee! Excellent!
::blinks at monitor::

But--I thought it was supposed to be *badfic*.

This

"Uh, okay, right," Rodney said, and shuffled for a little bit, and then he blurted, "So, I'm, I'm not in Physics 101."

"No?" John said.

"No, I'm actually a doctoral student," Rodney said, "and—oh. Wait, was that sarcasm? That was sarcasm, wasn't it."

"Yes, it was," John said patiently.

"Oh," Rodney said. "So, when did you—?"

"It kind of gave it away when that first problem you started us out with was stuff that's not even in the back of the textbook for the class," John said.

"Oh," Rodney said.

"You're a pretty decent tutor aside from all the yelling, though," John said.


was almost my favorite part, but this wins--

They took John's tuxedo off together, hands fumbling over each other as they worked on the studs and the cufflinks, the crisp white shirt spreading open over John's chest, so warm under Rodney's hands.

Let me know if you need any baby-havin' done.
I'm cracking up here. John as Princess Ancienta? And Rodney trying to convince them he's in Physics 101? There is no part of this that isn't awesome.

This puts the crack in crackfic. *hearts*
This was fantastic and very funny - also reminded me how *different* American colleges are, a completely alien landscape to us Brits!
S
Page 1 of 7
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] >>